· 6 items
Planning Commission, Thursday, October 1
On the episode: Oversight commissioner suspended; Flower Mart towers; a housing fee break
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Planning Commission Thursday, October 1
6 items
Election of officers: vice president Item 2
Appointments and leadership
The commission had a vacancy among its officers and elected a vice president. The chair explained that under the bylaws one officer post is held by a mayoral appointee and the other by an appointee of the Board president. All seven commissioners were present, and the commission elected Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) vice president 7-0. No one spoke in public comment. 00:01:34
- Lydia So (Commissioner), recognized by the chair, nominated Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) for vice president of the Planning Commission; the nomination was seconded. Result: passed, 7-0. 00:04:36Ayes: Malea Chavez, Mike Chen, Joel Koppel, Elizabeth Macdonald, Sean McGarry, Lydia So, Amy Campbell. From the clerk's record
- The commission secretary told commissioners there was a vacancy among the commission's officers and that they should take nominations and vote. 00:01:34
- A commissioner explained that the bylaws split the two officer posts between a mayoral appointee and a Board president appointee, and that as a mayoral appointee herself the nominations should go to Board president appointees. 00:02:46
- A commissioner nominated Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) for vice president, citing his knowledge and history with the commission, and welcomed a fully seated commission and his return to it. 00:03:16
- A commissioner accepted the nomination and said he would assist the president with the week-to-week process. 00:04:19
- A commissioner said he would keep his current seat rather than move to the seat traditionally taken by the vice president beside the president, and would move over when needed. 00:05:09
Director's announcements: Planning–DBI merger and earthquake exercise Item 3
Emergency preparedness
The planning director's regular report. City staff described the Planning Department's pending merger with the Department of Building Inspection (DBI) and an earthquake exercise held with Daniel Lurie (Mayor) and other department heads, and introduced the manager of the department's District 6 development review team. No action. 00:05:39
- City staff introduced the staff member who manages the department's District 6 development review team, saying almost every big or tall project the commission sees comes through that team. 00:05:52
- City staff said the main news of the week concerned Planning's pending merger with DBI and the roles the two departments will share. 00:05:52
- City staff reported taking part in an earthquake exercise with Daniel Lurie (Mayor), her DBI counterpart and other department heads, a practice run of roles in the first twelve hours after a disaster. 00:05:52
- City staff explained that DBI has inspectors trained under a state safety assessment program to inspect buildings after a disaster, and is training more. 00:06:53
Report on recent Board of Supervisors actions Item 4
Zoning and plans
The commission secretary's regular rundown of what happened to planning legislation at the Board of Supervisors and its Land Use and Transportation Committee. There was no Board of Appeals report and the Historic Preservation Commission had not met. No action. 00:08:30
- The commission secretary reported that the Land Use and Transportation Committee amended the story count and mezzanines ordinance to include the commission's recommended modifications, then continued it a week because the amendments were considered substantive. 00:08:30
- The commission secretary reported that the committee forwarded the local CEQA implementation administrative code item with a positive recommendation. 00:08:30
- The commission secretary reported that the Potrero Power Station development agreement package was forwarded with a positive recommendation and passed on first reading at the full Board. 00:08:30
- The commission secretary reported that ordinances on signs in mixed-use districts and on commercial-to-residential adaptive reuse passed on second reading, and a landmark designation amendment for the Sylvester House passed on first reading. 00:08:30
- The commission secretary reported that the Board adopted a resolution urging the Planning Department to report on the status of equity-oriented policy actions in the 2022 housing element. 00:08:30
Flower Mart development agreement amendment (informational) Item 5
Development projectsHousing supplyZoning and plans
An informational presentation, with no vote, on a proposed amendment to the 2019 development agreement for the roughly 6.5-acre Flower Mart site on Brannan Street between 5th and 6th streets in Central SoMa (case 2025-008569PRJ, agenda). The project sponsor is Kilroy Realty, with Gensler as designer. City staff said the 2019 approval was mainly office with ground-floor retail and a maximum height of 270, and that the wholesale flower market has already been relocated to a new building that opened in January 2025. The amendment would let the site be built as housing, commercial, institutional or a mix: up to 3,532 homes if entirely residential, or about 2.6 million square feet of commercial space; height limits of up to 600 feet for residential and 300 feet for commercial buildings; above-grade parking with facade screening; a new set of design standards; and a new 15-year term with one possible five-year extension. Staff said an affordable housing land dedication, public art, parks, clean-streets and workforce commitments stay in the agreement. The commissioner who had been chairing recused herself as an employee of Gensler, and Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) chaired the item. The project is to return for approvals after environmental review. 00:09:43
- Informational presentation only; no motion was made and no action was requested. Result: no action. 01:16:59
- A commissioner announced she was recusing herself from the item because she is an employee of Gensler, which is working on the project, and handed the chair to the vice president. 00:10:32
- City staff said the hearing was informational, with no commission action requested, and was meant to introduce the amendment and gather questions and feedback. 00:10:56
- City staff described the site as about 6.5 acres between 5th and 6th streets along Brannan, within the Central SoMa plan area and one of the plan's key sites. 00:11:58
- City staff said the 2019 approval was primarily commercial, with office and ground-floor retail and a maximum building height of 270, and included relocating and preserving the wholesale flower market as a public benefit. 00:11:58
- City staff said the flower market's relocation has happened, with the new market open since January 2025 and vendors operating there. 00:13:02
- City staff said the amended framework could allow up to 3,532 residential units if the site were entirely residential, or about 2.6 million square feet of commercial development, with institutional uses also possible. 00:13:02
- City staff said maximum heights could rise to 600 feet for residential projects only, or 300 feet for commercial development. 00:14:04
- City staff said the proposal would allow above-grade parking, but only with facade screening requirements. 00:14:04
- City staff said this was the first informational hearing on the amendment and that the project would return to the commission for approvals after environmental review is completed. 00:15:08
- A speaker speaking for the Office of Economic and Workforce Development, said the original 2019 agreement had a ten-year term with one five-year extension and the amendment would give the developer a new 15-year term with one possible five-year extension. 00:17:49
- A speaker said the community benefits still include an affordable housing land dedication, now with inclusionary units added if housing is built, and that public art, community space, parks, clean-streets and workforce commitments remain. 00:18:50
- A speaker said the notable change in the benefits is the obligation to retain and rebuild the flower market, since the sponsor has already built the new market. 00:18:50
- A guest presenter speaking for Kilroy Realty, argued that development is not feasible in Central SoMa today given construction costs, city requirements and the real estate market, and that the amendment is meant to create conditions for the project to be built. 00:20:02
- A guest presenter speaking for Gensler, described the design as a flexible framework: towers that can be built as the market allows, above a fixed public realm at ground level. 00:25:19
- A speaker speaking as Gensler's urban designer, said the plan adds new internal streets with a jog designed to reduce cut-through traffic, two connected open spaces and a set of alleys. 00:26:12
- A speaker said each parcel is designed to hold its own parking, placed above the active ground-floor uses. 00:30:39
- A commissioner recalled the Central SoMa plan's adoption and credited David Chiu (City Attorney) with helping form the housing sustainability district in the neighborhood. 00:37:33
- A commissioner voiced support for the revised project, including its mid-block alleys, screened above-ground parking and added housing. 00:38:35
- A speaker gave the project full support, saying too many approved projects in the area have sat idle and this one could get the neighborhood moving. 00:38:53
- Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) raised a concern that the draft design guidelines allow fences around the privately owned public open spaces without a limit on how long they could be up. 00:43:06
- Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) voiced concern about the above-grade parking, calling it a major change, and asked about the lower tier of screening along Brannan Street. 00:45:16
- A guest presenter answered that fencing of the open spaces is not required but is wanted as an option for closing them at night for safety, with the spaces open during the day. 00:46:58
- A speaker added that the conditions for operating any fences will be set out in the development agreement. 00:48:11
- A guest presenter explained the parking screening tiers: in the first the building's architecture continues down over the parking, while the second allows a different treatment for cost reasons but still screens the parking. 00:50:29
- A guest presenter said ground-floor residential is allowed by the design standards and that ground-floor townhomes could work on the site as they have in the Transbay and Rincon Hill area. 00:52:43
- Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) asked what is driving the 600-foot residential height limit and what inclusionary housing the agreement would require if housing is built. 00:54:03
- A guest presenter said the 600-foot limit matches what the project could have reached using the state density bonus program, which the sponsor agreed to waive in exchange for the city changing the height limit. 00:54:53
- A guest presenter said the sponsor agrees to meet citywide inclusionary housing requirements and to do so on-site for the 600-foot projects, giving up the off-site option for those. 00:55:55
- A speaker said an affordable housing parcel will be dedicated to the city whether or not housing is built on the site, and that the final benefits package is still being worked out. 00:56:16
- Lydia So (Commissioner) said the proposed heights are consistent with the city's future vision for that part of South of Market. 00:58:31
- Lydia So (Commissioner) asked that the towers vary in height rather than all match, as one diagram in the packet showed. 00:59:33
- Lydia So (Commissioner) said she preferred the first two parking screening options for the design standards and disliked the third. 01:00:34
- A guest presenter replied that the equal-height drawing is only a diagram and not prescriptive, and that the goal is varied heights. 01:03:02
- A guest presenter said the third screening type would be used only where parking faces loading areas and back alleys with little public view. 01:03:02
- Malea Chavez (Commissioner) asked what engagement with the cultural district community is continuing and what the commitment to it now looks like. 01:05:02
- A speaker said the city is still working with the cultural district and that the earlier, specific public art commitment is being reworked into a more flexible one. 01:06:03
- A speaker said the developer leads community engagement, with the city guiding which stakeholders are reached. 01:06:47
- A guest presenter said the cultural district art commitment from the original agreement carries over into the amendment, with details still being worked out. 01:07:08
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) asked about a provision in the design standards allowing gates and fences at access points to the site's private streets. 01:07:40
- City staff said gates on the streets would not be automatic: they would need the planning director's approval and the sponsor would have to show a safety concern, with the process spelled out in the agreement. 01:08:23
- A guest presenter said the sponsor has bought the land for the affordable housing dedication but has not yet transferred it to the city. 01:09:49
- A speaker clarified that the timing of the land transfer would be at the choice of the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development rather than tied to the first construction document. 01:10:32
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) raised concern that one stretch of a new street near 6th Street would have a sidewalk on only one side, and asked for sidewalks on both. 01:11:15
- City staff said the right of way there is too narrow for two sidewalks and that staff vetted the one-sidewalk design with a Public Works accessibility coordinator. 01:11:44
- City staff listed what will come back to the commission: a Planning Code amendment, a map amendment for height, the development agreement and the design standards. 01:13:08
- City staff said there will also be a joint hearing of the Planning and Recreation and Park commissions because the project casts a shadow. 01:13:20
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) said that if developers are given a choice between office and housing, policymakers should consider how to make housing as competitive to build as office. 01:13:38
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) suggested that above-grade parking with screening and design standards could be considered for other projects as a way to cut building costs. 01:15:46
Impact fee exemption for corner-lot housing projects Item 6
Housing supplyTaxes and fees
A Planning Code amendment (case 2026-004766PCA, agenda) sponsored by a member of the Board of Supervisors, a supervisor, who presented it. As introduced, it would exempt housing projects on corner lots that use the HCSF program in the Family Zoning Plan area from development impact fees for childcare, transit sustainability and applicable area plans, while keeping inclusionary housing requirements. Planning staff recommended approval with two changes: extend the exemption to all HCSF-eligible parcels, not just corner lots, and add a 2032 sunset date. The commission's vote is a recommendation. After a long debate over the sunset date, it voted 7-0 to recommend approval with the exemption extended to all eligible parcels and without the sunset. Staff said the fees fund infrastructure, transit and childcare but that collections from these parcels have been low; projects using the state density bonus or other ministerial pathways would keep paying the fees in full. 01:16:59
- Sean McGarry (Commissioner) moved to recommend approval; the commission secretary later described the motion as approval with both staff modifications (extend to all eligible parcels and add a 2032 sunset). Amy Campbell (Commissioner; President, Planning Commission) seconded and then withdrew her second; Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) later seconded. Sean McGarry (Commissioner) withdrew the motion before a vote. Result: withdrawn. 02:25:27
- Lydia So (Commissioner) moved to adopt a recommendation for approval with staff modification one only (extend the fee exemption to all HCSF-eligible parcels) and without the 2032 sunset date; seconded by Amy Campbell (Commissioner; President, Planning Commission). Result: passed, 7-0. 02:25:39Ayes: Malea Chavez, Mike Chen, Joel Koppel, Elizabeth Macdonald, Sean McGarry, Lydia So, Amy Campbell. From the clerk's record
- A supervisor said he introduced the legislation to eliminate non-inclusionary impact fees on corner lots under the Family Zoning Plan in order to cut construction costs. 01:20:21
- A supervisor said the median monthly rent for a one-bedroom apartment now exceeds $4,200. 01:19:20
- A supervisor argued impact fees bring the city little money but can cost developers an extra $27,000 per unit in some cases. 01:20:21
- A supervisor said corner lots account for more than half of the new-unit capacity under the Family Zoning Plan. 01:20:21
- A supervisor said he is also interested in using the legislation to consider a modest increase in the allowable average floor plate size on corner lots. 01:21:31
- A supervisor said he wants to explore similar fee reductions for housing created by adaptive reuse of historic buildings, probably in separate legislation. 01:21:31
- A speaker presenting for planning staff, said the ordinance would waive childcare, transit sustainability and applicable area plan fees in the Family Zoning Plan area while keeping inclusionary requirements. 01:23:26
- A speaker gave a figure for impact fees generated by HCSF-eligible parcels since September 2023, nearly all from childcare and transit fees and roughly $15,000 from area plan fees; the total is garbled in the recording. 01:23:26
- A speaker said studies from the 2025 rezoning found feasibility gaps of $80,000 to more than $400,000 per unit, against total development costs of about $1 million per unit. 01:24:30
- A speaker estimated the fee savings at $6,000 to $7,000 per unit for larger projects and about $530 for smaller ones, calling the relief modest but meaningful for projects on the edge of feasibility. 01:24:30
- A speaker said corner lots are about 10 percent of parcels but hold nearly half the rezoning capacity, and that so far seven HCSF applications have been mid-block and four on corner lots. 01:25:31
- A speaker acknowledged the exemptions reduce revenue for infrastructure, transit and childcare but said collections from these parcels have been low. 01:26:32
- A speaker noted that projects using the state density bonus or other ministerial pathways would still pay the fees in full. 01:26:32
- A speaker gave staff's first recommended change: extend the exemption to all HCSF parcels, since constraints are similar on corner and interior sites. 01:27:37
- A speaker gave staff's second recommended change: a 2032 sunset date so the exemption can be reassessed. 01:27:37
- A speaker backed the proposal as a five-year program that can be reassessed, and moved to approve. 01:30:35
- A commissioner argued against a sunset date, citing interest rates, labor and material costs, and made a second motion to approve with only staff's first recommended change. 01:34:54
- A commissioner withdrew her second of the first motion and seconded the motion without the sunset. 01:35:33
- A speaker answering for planning staff, said the fee rules are complex enough that staff sometimes have to double-check and have had to revise calculations. 01:36:31
- City staff said parcel-by-parcel differences in overlapping rules add complexity and time to reviews the department is trying to speed up. 01:38:06
- A speaker said planning staff will begin including analysis of administrative complexity in staff reports on legislation. 01:38:42
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) supported extending the exemption to all Family Zoning Plan sites, partly to ease the administrative burden. 01:40:32
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) argued the default should be that the fees stay off unless the city acts to restore them, and backed the motion without a sunset. 01:41:35
- Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) described the question as a balance between funding transit, childcare and neighborhood needs and encouraging housing, and said the balance tips toward housing. 01:43:56
- City staff explained that staff proposed the sunset as a regular check-in, as with the inclusionary reductions' three-year review, and that it would not necessarily mean reverting to today's fees. 01:46:13
- Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) seconded the motion to approve with both staff changes, including the sunset. 01:47:08
- Malea Chavez (Commissioner) voiced concern about transportation funding and favored the sunset as a chance to check on the impact and any unintended consequences. 01:49:00
- A commissioner said, speaking as chair, that 2032 is too close given how long development takes, and asked for a broader conversation about impact fees. 01:51:14
- Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) floated a longer sunset, such as ten years, as a possible compromise. 01:52:06
- City staff said the commission can expect a broad discussion of impact fees and other housing cost constraints in early 2027. 01:53:00
- City staff said the housing element has a circuit-breaker trigger in January 2027, when the city looks at whether more strategies or rezoning are needed to meet its housing goals. 01:53:00
- Lydia So (Commissioner) argued a sunset date would undermine the confidence of people deciding whether to invest in building housing in the city. 01:57:33
- Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) noted the ordinance has a second supervisor as co-author and asked the sponsor for his view on the two staff changes. 02:00:57
- A supervisor endorsed staff's first change, extending the exemption to all eligible parcels. 02:01:27
- A supervisor said that on the sunset he leaned toward the reasoning of the commissioners who opposed it, and that housing should not be pitted against transit and childcare for money. 02:01:27
- A speaker said he was conflicted: dropping the fees with no end date removes the option to reassess, and the money for transit and childcare would have to come from somewhere. 02:03:51
- Malea Chavez (Commissioner) maintained that a sunset carries little risk and would let the city learn whether removing the fees increases applications. 02:06:30
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) summed up three reasons against a sunset: the city can still act later either way, a sunset adds administrative burden, and dropping it signals the city is open to housing. 02:09:16
- A commissioner said she did not want to return to burdening housing projects with these fees in the near future and that there will be other chances to revisit how transit and childcare are funded. 02:09:53
- Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) came around to supporting approval without a sunset as a gesture of support for the Family Zoning Plan, while saying she still slightly preferred the other approach. 02:24:00
- A speaker withdrew his motion after the commissioner who had seconded it shifted her position. 02:25:27
Height limit exemption for required rooftop restrooms Item 7
Zoning and plansHousing supply
A Planning Code amendment (case 2026-007353PCA, agenda; Board file 260791) introduced by a member of the Board of Supervisors and presented by that supervisor's legislative aide. It would exempt restrooms that the plumbing code requires for common-use rooftop spaces from a building's height limit, adding them to existing exemptions such as elevator penthouses and stairways. The aide said the Department of Building Inspection stepped up enforcement of the restroom rule this year, leaving projects with common rooftop space to redesign the top floor and possibly lose homes, exceed the height limit, or build shorter. Staff recommended approval without modifications, and the commission voted 7-0 to recommend approval. 02:25:39
- Mike Chen (Commissioner) moved to recommend approval of the rooftop restroom height exemption, as staff recommended, without modifications; the motion was seconded. Result: passed, 7-0. 02:37:46Ayes: Malea Chavez, Mike Chen, Joel Koppel, Elizabeth Macdonald, Sean McGarry, Lydia So, Amy Campbell. From the clerk's record
- City staff introduced the item for planning staff, giving its Board file number and its sponsoring supervisor, and handed off to the sponsor's aide. 02:26:48
- A speaker speaking as the sponsoring supervisor's aide, said DBI stepped up enforcement earlier this year of a plumbing code rule requiring a restroom on or one floor below a common rooftop space. 02:27:00
- A speaker said projects such as the Freedom West co-op's senior housing and 3333 California face a choice of reworking the top floor, adding a rooftop restroom that would break the height limit or development agreement, or building shorter. 02:28:02
- A speaker said the legislation adds restrooms serving rooftop common areas to the list of features exempt from height limits. 02:28:02
- City staff flagged an error in the draft resolution: the ordinance is not a project under CEQA rather than categorically exempt, which staff will correct in the final resolution. 02:29:13
- City staff explained that putting the required restroom one story below the roof avoids the height issue but can cost interior space, possibly a dwelling unit. 02:29:13
- City staff said staff found no implementation concerns and recommended approval without modifications. 02:30:18
- A commissioner gave the amendment full support, calling it straightforward and modest and likely to open up opportunities for projects. 02:31:03
- City staff clarified that a private roof deck serving a single unit would not need a restroom; the requirement applies to common-use spaces above occupancy thresholds. 02:31:54
- A commissioner urged a proactive review of conflicts between the planning and building codes rather than fixing them one at a time as projects run into them, and offered to support more staff for it in the next budget cycle. 02:33:03
- City staff said limited staffing and the city's budget crunch have kept the department from doing a comprehensive review of code inconsistencies, which it still intends to do. 02:33:30
- City staff said staff already have lists of local building code amendments they want to change, though not yet covering the electrical, mechanical and other codes as fully. 02:35:40
- Malea Chavez (Commissioner) supported the item and said she hoped it would encourage more accessible common space on rooftops. 02:36:36
- Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) gave the amendment full support, calling it an easy decision. 02:37:13
Public comment
- General public comment: no one spoke.
- Election of officers (item 2): no one spoke.
- Flower Mart development agreement amendment (item 5): six speakers, all in support. They included two representatives of the San Francisco Chamber of Commerce (one said he formerly served on the commission), and representatives of the Bay Area Council, a carpenters union and the Housing Action Coalition, plus a longtime resident who works in construction. Themes: large projects need flexibility as conditions change, the site has sat idle for years, construction jobs, and the chance for up to about 3,500 homes near transit.
- Impact fees on corner lots (item 6): one speaker, from the Housing Action Coalition, supported waiving the fees on corner lots and all Family Zoning Plan lots and said the group has asked the sponsor to add a 10 percent larger allowable floor plate on corner lots. Staff said the department also received one email with questions.
- Rooftop restroom height exemption (item 7): no one spoke.
What's next
- Flower Mart: staff said the project will return to the commission for approvals after environmental review is completed. Staff listed a Planning Code amendment, a height map amendment, the development agreement amendment and the design standards and guidelines, plus a joint hearing with the Recreation and Park Commission on shadow. A commissioner referred to the development agreement amendment coming by the end of the year; staff did not give a date.
- Flower Mart: city staff said the final community benefits package, including inclusionary housing terms and the public art commitment to the cultural district, is still being worked out and will be brought back.
- Corner-lot impact fee ordinance: the commission's recommendation (approve, extend to all HCSF-eligible parcels, no sunset date) goes forward as a recommendation; the sponsor, a supervisor, said he is also considering a modest floor plate increase for corner lots and separate legislation on fee reductions for adaptive reuse of historic buildings.
- City staff said the commission can expect a broad discussion of impact fees and other housing cost constraints in early 2027, alongside the housing element's circuit-breaker review in January 2027, with conversations over the next six to nine months.
- Planning staff said they will begin including analysis of administrative complexity in staff reports on proposed legislation.
- Rooftop restroom ordinance: staff will correct the final resolution to say the ordinance is not a project under CEQA. City staff said the department intends a deeper review of inconsistencies between the planning and building codes when staffing allows and will keep the commission posted.
- The commission secretary reported that the story count and mezzanines ordinance was continued one week at the Board's Land Use and Transportation Committee.
Write to the Planning Commission before its next meeting: commissions.secretary@sfgov.org