CivicFM
San Francisco

· 10 items

Planning Commission, Thursday, October 8

On the episode: A pause on data centers, a shorter CEQA appeal window, self-checkout staff

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

Planning Commission Thursday, October 8

10 items

The recording · Agenda

55-59 Bemis Street discretionary review continued Item 1

Development projects

A discretionary review of a planning application for a vertical addition and a horizontal rear addition to an existing two-story building at 55-59 Bemis Street (agenda). It was proposed for continuance and was not heard on the merits. 00:01:23

  • Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) moved to continue item 1 to November 12, 2026. Result: continued, 6-0. 00:02:08Ayes: Malea Chavez, Mike Chen, Elizabeth Macdonald, Sean McGarry, Joel Koppel, Amy Campbell. Absent: Lydia So. From the clerk's record

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Minutes of September 17, 2026 Item 3

Adoption of the draft minutes of the commission's September 17, 2026 hearing. 00:03:14

  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) moved to adopt the September 17, 2026 minutes. Result: passed, 6-0. 00:03:38

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Commission comments and questions Item 4

Standing time for commissioners' comments and questions. No commissioner spoke. 00:04:07

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Director's update on merging Planning and the Department of Building Inspection Item 5

Taxes and feesBudgets

The Planning Director announced a permit center closure and gave the commission an update it had requested on the merger of the Planning Department with the Department of Building Inspection (DBI), which is meant to give residents and small businesses one permitting process instead of separate planning and building steps. She described what has merged so far, what DBI still runs on its own, and a target of one new department by July 2027, with a joint budget, a fee study and possible legislation along the way. 00:04:10

  • City staff announced that the Planning Department, the Planning Information Counter and the Permit Center would be closed Monday, October 12 for Indigenous Peoples' Day 00:04:18
  • City staff said the Mayor announced in January his intention to bring the two departments together 00:06:44
  • City staff said that for permits moved to digital-first service, almost 30 percent of applications now come in outside business hours 00:07:45
  • City staff said the merger is not about cutting staff, since both agencies need all their personnel, but about working better together 00:10:24
  • City staff described the first stage in March 2026, when the Permit Center moved from the City Administrator's office into the Planning Department and the two departments' technology teams combined 00:13:52
  • City staff said administrative services such as finance and human resources combined this summer, while DBI still runs its core services as an independent agency: permit intake and issuance, plan review, code enforcement and inspections 00:14:54
  • City staff said about 35 Permit Center staff and almost 40 technology staff joined in March 00:15:57
  • City staff said almost another 60 employees joined in administration, finance, records management, and policy and public affairs 00:17:00
  • City staff described the goal of fully merging into a new department by July 2027, which she said would need some legislation, including commission review 00:17:00
  • City staff said an internal fee study aims to hold permit fees steady or lower them while still funding core services 00:19:16
  • City staff responded to fears that each department would use the other's money, saying fees collected will go to permit and plan review 00:19:16
  • City staff said a joint budget for the July 1 merger will probably be proposed this winter, going to this commission (usually in February) and to the Building Inspection Commission 00:20:18
  • City staff said any cleanup legislation would likely be introduced next spring, with hearings at the Board of Supervisors 00:21:20

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Report on recent Board of Supervisors actions Item 6

Historic preservationData centersZoning and plans

Staff's regular report on actions by the Board of Supervisors, the Board of Appeals and the Historic Preservation Commission that affect planning, including landmark designations, an interim zoning moratorium on data centers, and changes to the city's local environmental review procedures. 00:22:12

  • The clerk reported there was no Board of Appeals report and that the Historic Preservation Commission hearing the day before was cancelled 00:22:12
  • The clerk reported that the Land Use and Transportation Committee duplicated the Compton's Cafeteria riot landmark file and added a finding urging the commissions to consider including interior features if new findings become available; that duplicate was continued to the call of the chair 00:22:12
  • The clerk reported that the original Compton's Cafeteria landmark file passed the full board on first reading 00:22:12
  • The clerk reported that the committee forwarded the story count and mezzanines ordinance with a positive recommendation 00:22:12
  • The clerk reported that the interim zoning moratorium on data centers passed the full board on first reading and will take effect immediately once enacted 00:23:14
  • The clerk reported that the Sylvester House landmark designation and the Potrero Power Station Development Agreement package passed on second reading, and the local CEQA implementation code passed on first reading 00:23:14

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Pier 92 sand facility: final environmental impact report certified Item 7

Warehouses and industryPollutionDevelopment projects

Certification of the Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for modernizing and replacing equipment at the marine sand processing plant at Pier 92, 480 Amador Street, on Port property in the northeast Bayview. The site is in a state-designated environmental justice community. The project adds covered conveyors, a 63-foot warehouse over the sand stockpile and truck loading area, paving and other dust controls, and expands the footprint from about 4.4 to 5.2 acres under a new Port lease. Certifying the EIR finds the environmental review adequate, accurate and complete. It does not approve the project, and the commission has no approval action on it. 00:24:21

  • Motion to certify the Final Environmental Impact Report for the Pier 92 Modernization and Plant Replacement Project (mover unclear; seconded by a commissioner). Result: passed, 6-0. 00:35:02Ayes: Malea Chavez, Mike Chen, Elizabeth Macdonald, Sean McGarry, Joel Koppel, Amy Campbell. Absent: Lydia So. From the clerk's record
  • City staff explained that certification means the EIR followed state and local environmental law, and is not an approval of the project 00:26:08
  • City staff described the 4.4-acre site as zoned heavy industrial and used for offloading and processing marine sand since 1982 00:26:52
  • City staff said about 65 percent of the finished sand goes to two neighboring ready-mix concrete plants, with most of the rest used in the city 00:28:10
  • City staff said the dust controls include covering conveyors and building a 63-foot warehouse over the finished stockpile and truck loading areas 00:28:10
  • City staff said the sponsor has applied to the air district to process up to 80,800 tons of sand in any 12-month period, though operations would still follow market demand 00:29:10
  • City staff said construction would last up to seven months in 2027, with sand operations continuing where possible 00:29:10
  • City staff said all impacts were found less than significant or none, with archaeological impacts less than significant after a discovery mitigation measure, and air quality impacts less than significant 00:30:56
  • City staff said the draft EIR drew 10 comments, five of them spoken at the June 25 hearing, and none required changes or identified new significant impacts 00:30:56
  • Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) praised the analysis and noted that air quality would improve and the neighboring wetland and bird sanctuary would not be significantly affected 00:32:56
  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) called the upgrade long overdue, saying the site's infrastructure has been deteriorating since the 1980s and the concrete trucks that build the city come from there 00:33:47
  • A commissioner said commissioners appeared to find the review adequate, accurate and complete, and invited a motion to certify 00:34:33

Write to the Planning Commission about this

101 Otsego Avenue: merger of unauthorized unit approved Item 8

Development projectsHousing supply

A conditional use authorization to merge an unauthorized first-floor dwelling unit with the legal second-floor unit at 101 Otsego Avenue, in a single-family (RH-1) district in Supervisor District 11, turning the building back into a single-family home. Staff said no tenant would be displaced. 00:35:26

  • Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) moved to approve with conditions; seconded by a commissioner. Result: passed, 7-0. 00:40:58Ayes: Malea Chavez, Mike Chen, Elizabeth Macdonald, Sean McGarry, Lydia So, Joel Koppel, Amy Campbell. From the clerk's record
  • City staff explained that the 1924 single-family house was split in 2019, with the owner living on the first floor and renting out the second floor until 2021 00:36:45
  • City staff said staff found no evictions tied to the property in rent board records 00:36:45
  • City staff said a planning code enforcement case was opened in January 2024 after a complaint from the public 00:36:45
  • City staff said the department received no letters for or against the project 00:37:45
  • City staff recommended approval with conditions, saying it would restore a single-family home consistent with the neighborhood and the zoning 00:37:45
  • The project sponsor said the owner wants to move back in, and the work would remove a wall and door at the stairs and turn the first-floor kitchen back into a wet bar to resolve the enforcement case 00:40:01

Write to the Planning Commission about this

3832 18th Street SB 423 presentation continued Item 9

Housing supplyDevelopment projects

An informational presentation on a housing project proposed at 3832 18th Street under SB 423, the state's streamlined approval law (Government Code Section 65913.4). The project sponsor's team asked late for a continuance, so the presentation was moved to November 5. As an informational item it carries no vote on the project. 00:40:58

  • Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) moved to continue item 9 to November 5, 2026. Result: continued, 7-0. 00:42:29Ayes: Malea Chavez, Mike Chen, Elizabeth Macdonald, Sean McGarry, Lydia So, Joel Koppel, Amy Campbell. From the clerk's record
  • The clerk reported a late continuance request for the item, which was only an informational SB 423 presentation 00:40:58

Write to the Planning Commission about this

701 Taraval Street: Alloy Personal Training formula retail gym approved Item 2

Small businessDevelopment projects

A conditional use authorization for a formula retail gym, Alloy Personal Training, in a vacant ground-floor storefront at 701 Taraval Street, in the Inner Taraval neighborhood commercial district. Chain businesses need this authorization so the commission can weigh how many chains a corridor already has. Mike Chen (Commissioner) pulled the item off the consent calendar. Staff said it would raise the share of formula retail storefronts within 300 feet from 4 to 8 percent. Commissioners debated community commitments, an illuminated sign and a mural, then approved the authorization as recommended. 00:42:29

▶ Hear it Would banning a lit sign just punish a chain? · 1:03

  • A commissioner proposed adding three conditions: indirect or no sign illumination, a review process for the mural, and disclosure of a community-benefit program. Result: no action. 01:18:15
  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) moved to approve with conditions as recommended by staff; seconded by a commissioner. Result: passed, 7-0. 01:22:22Ayes: Malea Chavez, Mike Chen, Elizabeth Macdonald, Sean McGarry, Lydia So, Joel Koppel, Amy Campbell. From the clerk's record
  • City staff reported that within 300 feet, formula retail would rise from 4 to 8 percent of storefronts and from 27 to 34 percent of street frontage 00:43:10
  • City staff said the gym would fill a vacant space, that about 8 percent of nearby commercial spaces are vacant, that no public comment was received, and that staff recommends approval with conditions 00:44:11
  • The project sponsor described the owners as Sunnyside residents with three franchise licenses, all for San Francisco, running small-group strength training aimed at people over 40; this would be the first Alloy location in the city 00:46:30
  • The project sponsor said sessions train six people at a time and the goal is to build community around health in later life 00:49:40
  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) thanked the owners for choosing San Francisco and filling a vacant storefront, and moved to approve 00:51:08
  • The project sponsor said the owners had joined People of Parkside and plan to partner with local businesses, support local races and schools, and donate to nonprofits 00:53:40
  • A commissioner pressed the sponsors for concrete community commitments already made, such as access for people who cannot afford membership, rather than future plans 00:54:30
  • A commissioner asked that the illuminated sign be made non-illuminated as part of the motion 00:56:43
  • City staff said the proposed sign meets the district's sign rules, and the added louvers still meet storefront transparency requirements 00:56:22
  • The project sponsor said the building owner lives directly above the space and has approved the plans, including the lit sign 00:58:47
  • A commissioner asked about community offerings such as neighborhood discounts and whether the gym is accessible for seniors 00:59:06
  • The project sponsor said the gym is meant to be accessible to all ages, but the owners had no specific pricing or discount offer to share yet, though they control those decisions and could come back with one 01:00:03
  • Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) supported the project, saying it would build community and is not the kind of formula retail that outprices local businesses 01:03:41
  • A commissioner said formula retail rules target large chains, that the commission looks at the use rather than the user, and that she would not make community involvement a condition of approval 01:05:12
  • City staff confirmed that the required formula retail findings on concentration, frontage and vacancy apply to every formula retail conditional use 01:06:01
  • Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) said this kind of gym meets a need for older adults, preferred a non-illuminated sign, and asked whether the storefront mural would remain 01:07:49
  • The project sponsor said the part of the mural painted on the window plywood would be lost when the boards come down, and that no one raised concerns at the neighborhood meeting 01:08:36
  • A commissioner established through staff that the sign is fully code-compliant, so a local business next door could have the same sign, and denying it would rest only on formula retail status 01:10:29
  • A commissioner proposed amending the motion to require indirect illumination, a review process for the mural, and disclosure of a community-benefit program, citing seniors of limited means in the area 01:16:10
  • Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) said the business needs discretion over who joins, because members must pass a physical intake for safety and liability reasons 01:19:22
  • Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) said he was okay with the illuminated sign 01:20:55
  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) described the business as boutique wellness training rather than a typical gym, asked that the motion stand as made, and called the question 01:21:17

Write to the Planning Commission about this

395 3rd Street: 45-story SB 423 housing tower presentation Item 10

Housing supplyDevelopment projectsAffordable housing

An informational presentation, with no vote, on a revised housing project at 395 3rd Street (at Harrison) submitted under SB 423, the state's streamlined approval law. The developer described 501 homes in 45 stories, 10 percent of them affordable on site, and 3,600 square feet of corner retail. The main change from the version approved in 2023 is moving parking above ground and cutting most of the underground construction, which the developer said saves about $30 million and six months. Under SB 423 the department reviews the project ministerially, without a commission vote. 01:22:22

▶ Hear it What above-ground parking saves for each new home · 0:42

  • Informational presentation; no vote taken. Result: no action. 01:44:22
  • A speaker said the developer acquired the site in 2021 and won unanimous approval for a high-rise in 2023, and now proposes 501 homes in 45 stories with 10 percent on-site affordable units and corner retail 01:24:29
  • A speaker said the units the firm has built were built with union labor and this project will be too 01:25:30
  • A speaker said cutting most underground work and lifting parking above the ground floor saves about $30 million in construction costs and about six months 01:25:30
  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) commended the developer for union labor and for putting the affordable units on site 01:31:17
  • City staff said the local inclusionary rate was lowered to 5 percent, but SB 423 requires 10 percent, which this project combines with state density bonus affordability requirements 01:32:48
  • A speaker said the developer expects to finish SB 423 entitlement in about six months and targets a 2028 construction start, with a schedule of about 24 months instead of 30 01:35:04
  • A commissioner praised the design, noted the affordable mix of 33 one-bedroom and 12 two-bedroom units, and encouraged more larger units for families 01:35:54
  • Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) praised the developer as San Francisco-based and said it builds what the commission approves 01:37:03
  • A commissioner said the abbreviated packet raised concerns, but the presentation showed attention to the ground floor and public realm; asked that the screen on the above-ground parking be designed well 01:38:52
  • A speaker worked out that the savings come to about $60,000 per unit and suggested the city consider allowing above-ground parking more widely, including in its tall zones 01:40:36
  • A speaker noted the item is informational and the department has 180 days to review the application 01:40:36
  • Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) cautioned that a lot of above-ground parking can harm the pedestrian environment and said any policy change needs a nuanced discussion 01:42:04
  • A commissioner noted broad support and that there is no vote because the item is informational 01:44:22

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Public comment

  • No members of the public spoke during general public comment, or on agenda items 1, 2, 3, 7 or 8 (Bemis, Taraval, minutes, Pier 92, Otsego).
  • On the 18th Street continuance (agenda item 9), one resident asked why the item was being continued; told it was the sponsor's request, the resident said they would return November 5.
  • On item 10, the same resident spoke mainly about the continued 18th Street project and SB 423. The resident said 71 percent of SB 423 projects the city has approved are nine units or fewer and 43 percent are two to three units, urged the city to ask Sacramento to limit no-hearing approval under the law to projects of four units or more, and criticized stair penthouses on plans.

What's next

  • Item 1 (55-59 Bemis Street discretionary review) is continued to November 12, 2026.
  • Item 9 (3832 18th Street SB 423 informational presentation) is continued to November 5, 2026.
  • The Planning Department, Planning Information Counter and Permit Center were to be closed Monday, October 12 for Indigenous Peoples' Day.
  • Planning and DBI expect to propose a joint budget this winter, going to the Planning Commission (usually in February) and the Building Inspection Commission.
  • Legislation to carry out the Planning-DBI merger is likely to be introduced in spring 2027, with commission review and Board of Supervisors hearings; the target for the new combined department is July 1, 2027.
  • The Planning Director offered to calendar more questions on the merger and a presentation by DBI leaders on DBI's core services.
  • The 395 3rd Street developer expects to finish SB 423 entitlement in about six months and targets a 2028 construction start; the department has 180 days to review the application.
  • Pier 92 construction is planned for up to seven months in 2027; the commission had no approval action on the project itself.

Write to the Planning Commission before its next meeting: commissions.secretary@sfgov.org

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error