CivicFM
San Francisco

· 13 items

Planning Commission, Thursday, November 5

On the episode: Commission opposes demolition rules unless changed; Crocker Amazon Park debate

Corrected . The page said Supervisor Chen would accept some amendments but not staff's recommendation two, its deletion of the PEG SUD's own replacement rules. Before the vote she accepted part of it, keeping rent-controlled replacement units; what she held to was the deeper affordability those rules require, which staff said remained outstanding. The page now says so, and that the ordinance would change the replacement rules, where it had them as already changed. What changed

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

Planning Commission Thursday, November 5

13 items

The recording · Agenda

Discretionary review at 32 Ellert Street withdrawn Item 13

Development projects

A request for discretionary review of an attic addition for a new primary bedroom at 32 Ellert Street was withdrawn before the hearing, so the commission did not hear it. 00:00:00

  • Withdrawal announced by the commission secretary; no vote. Result: withdrawn. 00:01:07

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Discretionary review at 116 18th Avenue withdrawn Item 14

Development projects

A request for discretionary review of a project at 116 18th Avenue was withdrawn before the hearing. The project adds two floors, extends the building horizontally and adds a new dwelling unit. 00:00:00

  • Withdrawal announced by the commission secretary; no vote. Result: withdrawn. 00:01:07

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Consent calendar: cannabis store at 3326 Mission, massage business at 4444 Geary, yard-structures code amendment Item B

CannabisZoning and plansSmall business

Three routine items passed in one vote: a conditional use authorization to legalize a formula retail cannabis store at 3326 Mission Street, a conditional use authorization for a new massage establishment at 4444 Geary Boulevard, Suite 210, and a Planning Code amendment (Board file 260963) that extends eligibility for unpermitted residential yard structures. No member of the public asked to pull any of them. 00:01:07

  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) moved to approve the consent calendar (items 1–3); seconded. Result: passed, 7-0. 00:02:09

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Minutes of October 8 and October 15, 2026 Item 4

The commission adopted the draft minutes of its October 8 and October 15, 2026 meetings. 00:03:05

  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) moved to adopt the minutes; seconded. Result: passed, 7-0. 00:03:26

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Commission comments and questions Item 5

No commissioner asked to speak. 00:03:26

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Director's announcements: Planning–Building merger, joint budget, fees Item 6

Taxes and feesBudgets

The director reported that voters had approved Measure F, which lets the Planning Department and the Department of Building Inspection finish merging. A joint budget and a fee review will come to the commission early next year. 00:04:01

  • The planning director said voters approved Measure F, which will let Planning and Building complete their merger, and listed steps already taken, including folding the Permit Center into Planning 00:04:01
  • The planning director said a joint budget for the merged department, with integrated fees, will come to the commission early next year, possibly at a joint hearing 00:04:01
  • The planning director said both departments expect fee surpluses this year, which they hope will let them hold fees steady next year and possibly lower them 00:05:04
  • The planning director announced that the Planning Department and the Permit Center will be closed on November 11 00:05:04

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Report on the Board of Appeals, Board of Supervisors and Historic Preservation Commission Item 7

Historic preservationDevelopment projects

Staff reported actions by other bodies. The Board of Appeals kept a permit fully suspended at a 25th Street home where more of the building was demolished than allowed; that project will now need a conditional use authorization from this commission. Staff also gave updates on landmark designations and ordinances moving through the Board of Supervisors. 00:05:51

  • The zoning administrator reported that the Board of Appeals voted 3-1 to deny the owner's appeal and keep the full permit suspension on a 25th Street project where more of the existing building was removed than authorized 00:07:09
  • The zoning administrator said the revised project will need a conditional use authorization and will come to the commission in the coming months 00:08:12
  • The commission secretary reported that the Land Use and Transportation Committee considered more than 20 landmark designations in Districts 2 and 3 and forwarded all but two of them. The Inverness garage was tabled because its owner opposed it, and the Brown Metzger mansion was continued to November 30. 00:08:53
  • The commission secretary reported that the full Board passed the rooftop restroom height-exemption ordinance and the Jefferson Airplane House landmark designation on first read 00:09:54

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Supervisor's ordinance on replacing demolished housing in priority equity geographies (Board File 260836) Item 8

Affordable housingRenters and tenantsZoning and plans
A map of the PEG Special Use District, with the 30 blocks south of Ocean Avenue that the proposed map amendments would add shown in pink.
A map of the PEG Special Use District, with the 30 blocks south of Ocean Avenue that the proposed map amendments would add shown in pink. Shown at the Planning Commission, Nov 5 · 00:50:01

This ordinance, introduced by Chyanne Chen (Supervisor, District 11), would amend the Planning Code and Zoning Map. It would change how many affordable units a developer must build to replace homes it tears down. As drafted, it would: extend the citywide look-back period for one-to-one replacement of housing from five to seven years; in the Priority Equity Geographies Special Use District (PEG SUD), use neighborhood-specific federal CHAS data when tenant incomes are unknown, which raises the affordable share of replacement units from about 51% to about 69% and, for rental projects, adds an extremely low income tier (30% of area median income) at about 41%; in PEG SUD rental projects, replace rent-controlled units held by moderate- or higher-income tenants with deed-restricted units at 80% AMI instead of rent-controlled units; add about 30 blocks south of Ocean Avenue to the PEG SUD; and, citywide, switch replacement units to the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD) income limits, which are lower than the state's, plus cleanup amendments. Staff recommended a new kind of action, disapproval unless modified, with three changes: keep the five-year look-back, delete the PEG SUD-specific replacement requirements, and delete the map amendment. Before the vote, the supervisor said she could accept the first and third changes and, from the second, keeping rent-controlled replacement units, if the department committed to keep working on extremely low income units; staff said the PEG SUD's deeper affordability was what remained outstanding. The commission's recommendation goes to the Board of Supervisors. 00:16:16

  • Mike Chen (Commissioner) moved to adopt a recommendation of disapproval unless modified, following the staff recommendation, and to encourage the Board of Supervisors to increase protections for extremely low income tenants; seconded by Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission). Result: passed, 5-2. No: Malea Chavez (Commissioner), Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner). 03:17:20
  • The sponsoring supervisor described the ordinance as a narrow change to replacement-housing standards for projects that tear down existing homes in priority equity geographies 00:23:07
  • The sponsoring supervisor said state law, including SB 330, allows local rules on demolition that protect lower-income households more 00:19:58
  • The sponsoring supervisor said 52% of the city's low income renters live in the priority equity geographies 00:27:12
  • City staff explained that the ordinance extends the replacement look-back from five to seven years citywide 00:28:12
  • City staff explained that staff was proposing a new kind of recommendation, disapproval unless modified, backed by separate findings of consistency and inconsistency with the General Plan 00:31:14
  • City staff said demolitions are rare in San Francisco, averaging about 18 units a year since 2012 00:34:28
  • City staff said that since the tenant protection ordinance took effect in February 2026 the department has received eight demolition applications, none of them in the PEG SUD 00:35:32
  • City staff said citywide data now require about 51% of replacement units to be affordable when incomes are unknown, and PEG-specific data would raise that to about 69% 00:38:49
  • City staff said MOHCD income limits are roughly 23% lower than the state's, which would mean deeper affordability citywide 00:40:53
  • City staff argued that raising replacement obligations without offsetting measures could make fewer housing projects financially feasible 00:44:26
  • City staff said that in the department's example of a 25-unit rental replacing a five-unit rent-controlled building, the proposal would make 20% of the project affordable, four times the inclusionary requirement 00:45:32
  • City staff warned the proposal could push projects from rental to ownership housing and take away moderate-income tenants' right to return 00:46:35
  • City staff said extremely low income units work best with dedicated subsidies and services that market-rate buildings lack 00:48:44
  • City staff advised against adding the 30 blocks to the PEG SUD now, saying it would set a precedent for parcel-by-parcel changes 00:49:47
  • Mike Chen (Commissioner) asked how current law protects single-room-occupancy (SRO) hotel units from demolition 01:56:28
  • City staff said every demolition inside the PEG SUD still requires a commission hearing, and that the hotel conversion ordinance requires one-for-one replacement of SRO units or an equivalent fee 01:58:12
  • City staff said that when tenant incomes are known, replacement units must be deed-restricted at the tenant's income level, at the current rent or an affordable rent, whichever is lower 02:02:02
  • City staff said staff knows of no SRO units demolished through these processes in its records 02:03:24
  • City staff confirmed that under the proposal, moderate-income tenants would lose their right to return in rental projects 02:09:47
  • Mike Chen (Commissioner) worried that deeper affordability requirements would make replacement projects infeasible 02:12:06
  • Mike Chen (Commissioner) argued that subsidies for very low income housing should come from sources like the housing trust fund, and said he leaned toward the staff recommendation 02:13:06
  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) said the city needs to build more and the change is not economically feasible now, and backed the recommendation because it keeps the conversation going 02:16:15
  • A commissioner asked whether the supervisor's office and the department could still work out their differences before the commission acted 02:17:15
  • The sponsoring supervisor said she was open to some amendments, but not to all of them, especially in staff's recommendation two, which she said goes to the legislation's core intent 02:21:02
  • City staff said the department's central sticking point is that new constraints on development must be offset, but that it remains open to other solutions 02:22:30
  • Lydia So (Commissioner) framed the question as whether the ordinance would actually protect the tenants it targets, and said it would create a parallel rulebook for an area with no demolition applications this year 02:26:36
  • Lydia So (Commissioner) argued that extremely low income households are better served through the housing trust fund that voters expanded with Prop C, and said she would support the staff recommendation 02:29:42
  • Lydia So (Commissioner) asked staff to track demolition-rule outcomes in the PEG and return with further cleanup, including making the right of first refusal automatic 02:32:46
  • A commissioner praised the community input but said he would side with the staff recommendation, citing builders' need for predictability and feasibility 02:37:16
  • The supervisor's legislative aide explained that the 30 added blocks meet the public health vulnerability criteria originally used to draw the priority equity geographies 02:39:33
  • The sponsoring supervisor said she was open to dropping the map amendment and keeping the five-year look-back 02:41:27
  • Elizabeth Macdonald (Commissioner) argued that a citywide standard is not an equitable standard, and suggested that problems with extremely low income units could be addressed in later legislation 02:43:35
  • A commissioner said that in her eviction defense work as an attorney, seniors on fixed incomes are the fastest-growing group she sees, and opposed letting uncertain feasibility block the legislation 02:52:31
  • The commission president said the tenant protection ordinance is already strong, expressed concern about the feasibility findings, and leaned toward disapproval unless modified 02:55:34
  • City staff said the commission must send its recommendation to the clerk by December 17, and that missing the deadline counts as a de facto disapproval 02:58:26
  • The sponsoring supervisor said that, from staff's recommendation two, she could also accept keeping rent-controlled replacement units, but only if the department commits to finding ways to give the most vulnerable access to extremely low income units, the legislation's intent 03:00:34
  • A commissioner proposed voting on the staff recommendations separately; staff said the commission must take one comprehensive action 03:07:45
  • The sponsoring supervisor stressed that the ordinance concerns replacing demolished homes rather than new inclusionary units, and that the Controller's feasibility study addressed inclusionary units 03:14:36

Write to the Planning Commission about this

40 12th Street: adult sex venue (bathhouse) approved Item 9a

Development projects

A conditional use authorization to convert a 7,516-square-foot two-story building at 40 12th Street (District 6) into an adult sex venue. Staff said it would be the first such venue authorized since the Planning Code was amended in 2022 to make the use legal. The work includes infilling two garage doors and curb cuts, removing a mezzanine, and excavating 30 cubic yards of soil. Conditions of approval require noise attenuation, lighting and security. 03:18:43

  • Joel Koppel (Commissioner; Vice President, Planning Commission) moved to approve with conditions as recommended by staff; seconded by Amy Campbell (Commissioner; President, Planning Commission). Result: passed, 7-0. 03:34:09
  • City staff said it would be the first adult sex venue authorized since the 2022 code change, and described the history of the city's bathhouse closures during the AIDS crisis 03:18:43
  • The project sponsor described the project as a professionally managed wellness bathhouse for the LGBTQ community, with controlled entry, staff training and security 03:22:36
  • The commission president asked about planned operating hours and urged the operator to be a good neighbor 03:30:23
  • The project sponsor said the hours are not settled and may be 24 hours, and that the venue will be professionally managed 03:31:40
  • The zoning administrator pointed to a condition requiring lighting and security that does not negatively affect neighbors 03:33:23

Write to the Planning Commission about this

40 12th Street: storefront transparency variance Item 9b

Development projects

A variance from the Planning Code's ground-floor transparency and visibility rules, because the venue's windows will not all be see-through. The zoning administrator decides this, not the commission. 03:18:43

  • The zoning administrator said the storefront windows will be kept and restored but not left see-through, so a future use could restore visibility 03:28:46
  • The zoning administrator found the project meets the variance requirements and said he intends to grant it 03:29:55
  • The zoning administrator closed the variance hearing and announced his intent to grant it with standard conditions 03:34:09

Write to the Planning Commission about this

301 Mission Street: legalizing a merged penthouse Item 10

Development projectsHousing supply

A conditional use authorization to legalize the merger of two two-bedroom penthouse units (PH 4 and PH 5) into one four-bedroom unit at the 11-story building at 301 Mission Street, part of the Millennium Tower. The units were merged without a permit around 2008–2009 and have only ever been owner-occupied. The city's policy generally discourages mergers that reduce housing units. Staff recommended approval with conditions and reported four letters in support. 03:34:18

  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) moved to approve with conditions; seconded by Amy Campbell (Commissioner; President, Planning Commission). Result: passed, 6-1. No: Lydia So (Commissioner). 03:46:34
  • City staff said the merger happened without a permit under the first owner shortly after the building was finished, and that the merged unit has always been owner-occupied 03:34:31
  • The project sponsor's attorney argued that construction plans show the units were combined before anyone moved in and never existed as two homes 03:37:53
  • The project sponsor's attorney argued that no housing is actually lost because the unit is not rent-controlled and has always been owner-occupied, and that the owner would face financial hardship 03:38:55
  • A speaker said, as the homeowner, that the assessor's office had told them before purchase that the penthouse counted as a single unit 03:40:17
  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) said early Millennium Tower buyers could not have known what they would face, and moved to approve 03:42:35
  • Lydia So (Commissioner) said she was torn because of the policy against reducing housing stock, and urged buyers to verify title and records 03:43:17
  • The commission president supported approval, saying the two units existed only on paper, no tenants were displaced, and larger units diversify housing 03:45:23

Write to the Planning Commission about this

3832 18th Street: informational presentation on an SB 423 housing project Item 11

Development projectsHousing supply

An informational presentation, with no vote, on a project near Dolores Park that will seek streamlined ministerial approval under state law SB 423. The plan keeps the existing single-family home, adds horizontal and vertical additions with one new unit in the main building, and builds a detached accessory dwelling unit at the rear, for three units in total. An earlier proposal for a larger group-housing building under the state density bonus was dropped. 03:47:47

  • The project sponsor's representative said the completed project would have three units, two more than now, and is meant to meet SB 423's minimum housing requirement 03:48:58
  • Mike Chen (Commissioner) asked why the project stops at 40 feet when the Family Zoning Plan appears to allow 50 03:54:51
  • The project sponsor's representative said the choice was financial: the owners want to live there, and a larger building would need elevators and other costly safety features 03:55:40
  • The commission secretary said taller buildings usually bring added exiting and elevator requirements 03:56:14
  • The commission president said the commission's comments are advisory only under SB 423, and voiced support 03:57:34

Write to the Planning Commission about this

3837 18th Street: neighbor's discretionary review of a third-floor addition Item 12

Development projects

A neighbor asked the commission to use discretionary review on a 950-square-foot third-floor addition at the rear of a two-story single-family home. The neighbor cited lost light and a boxed-in feeling. During mediation the owners switched to a sloped roof and lowered the ceiling and parapet. Staff found no exceptional or extraordinary circumstances and recommended not taking discretionary review and approving the modified design. The debate also raised whether the commission should stop rewarding discretionary review filings. 03:58:02

  • Sean McGarry (Commissioner) moved to not take discretionary review and approve the project as modified; seconded. Result: passed, 4-3. No: Mike Chen (Commissioner), Lydia So (Commissioner), Amy Campbell (Commissioner; President, Planning Commission). 04:40:48
  • City staff described the 950-square-foot rear addition and recommended not taking discretionary review and approving it as modified 03:59:40
  • A resident asked that the addition be set back three feet from the side property line to protect light and openness 04:04:04
  • The project sponsor said the owners had lowered, shortened and sloped the addition, and that their own sun study found the sloped roof gives back more light than a three-foot setback 04:09:24
  • Mike Chen (Commissioner) saw no extraordinary circumstances and said he was inclined to approve the original, pre-review design 04:16:00
  • The commission president disclosed living near the property but said there is no financial conflict, saw no extraordinary circumstances, and was open to freeing the owners from some of the concessions 04:16:54
  • A commissioner said he did not want to undo what the neighbors had already worked out 04:25:02
  • A commissioner argued that filing for discretionary review costs little while costing project sponsors and staff a lot, and that outcomes only ever move toward the filer 04:27:03
  • City staff said the citywide objective design standards do not apply to this project, which falls under the discretionary residential design guidelines 04:32:28
  • The commission secretary said the commission could direct staff to negotiate differently with future discretionary review filers on code-complying projects 04:36:19
  • A resident said, when asked, that they could accept the modified design 04:38:31

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Public comment

  • General public comment: three speakers. One urged commissioners to read a timeline of the city's residential demolition rules (Section 317) and argued the current demolition calculations are not strict enough. A community organization presented a survey-based report on the housing needs of low income residents, seniors, immigrants and people of color. A third speaker began reading a letter on item 8 and was told to wait for that item.
  • Item 8 (demolition replacement ordinance): about 20 speakers, all supporting the ordinance. About seven were low income residents, mostly families and seniors living in Chinatown SROs, who described crowded rooms and fear of being priced out if their buildings are rebuilt. Representatives of community and tenant organizations in the Mission, SoMa, Bayview Hunters Point and Chinatown argued that citywide standards don't fit the lower incomes in priority equity geographies, that replacement and inclusionary requirements are separate obligations, and that the Controller's feasibility study did not address this proposal. Several asked the department to keep working with community groups. One speaker read a high school student's letter, saying about 20 youth letters had been sent. Another proposed adding a stricter demolition definition for the PEG SUD.
  • Item 9a/9b (40 12th Street): one speaker, a board member of the Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District who runs a nearby business, supported the project as reviving an empty building and restoring a part of LGBTQ history.
  • Item 10 (301 Mission Street): no public comment.
  • Item 11 (3832 18th Street): one speaker criticized the project as an example of a loophole in SB 423, questioned how it avoids the demolition calculations, and predicted the units will be very expensive.
  • Item 12 (3837 18th Street): no public comment.

What's next

  • Item 8: the commission's recommendation of disapproval unless modified goes to the Board of Supervisors; staff said the deadline to send the final action to the clerk was December 17. The Land Use and Transportation Committee could take up amendments the sponsoring supervisor said she would accept (five-year look-back, dropping the map amendment, keeping rent-controlled replacement units). Staff described a possible new Board file that would bring the PEG affordability provisions back to the commission later.
  • Lydia So (Commissioner) asked staff to track demolition-rule outcomes in the priority equity geographies and return with further cleanup items, including making the right of first refusal automatic.
  • Staff said the tenant protection ordinance requires a report to the commission on demolition and eviction trends within a three-year span.
  • Joint budget for the merged Planning Department and Department of Building Inspection, with a fee review, to come to the commission early next year, possibly at a joint hearing.
  • The Planning Department and the Permit Center will be closed Wednesday, November 11.
  • A conditional use authorization for the 25th Street project, whose permit the Board of Appeals kept suspended, will come to the commission in the coming months.
  • Land Use and Transportation Committee: the landmark and historic district designation ordinance was continued to November 16, and the Brown Metzger mansion landmark designation to November 30.
  • The zoning administrator stated his intent to grant the 40 12th Street transparency variance with standard conditions.
  • The 3832 18th Street project will continue through SB 423 ministerial review with planning staff.

Write to the Planning Commission before its next meeting: commissions.secretary@sfgov.org

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error